Many of its details will survive intact, in my opinion, but it may go off the rails just a bit at one point, in damasio s discussion of what he calls the metaself. The knowledge is about social world and state of organism. Nov 06, 2012 click on a datetime to view the file as it appeared at that time. A readers journal descartes error emotion, reason, and. Heres his statement of what he calls descartes error. The book would be better titled descartes truth or damasios error. Top 10 things i did wrong on my youtube channel duration. The one who remains silent when i talk, the one who forgives, sweet, when i hate, the one who takes a walk when i am indoors, the one who will remain standing when i. What is missing from this book is the realization that the self, the source of free will and the decisions we. What is missing from this book is the realization that the self, the source of free will and the decisions we make is not to be found exclusively in our heads. Emotion, reason, and the human brain is a 1994 book by neurologist antonio damasio, in part a treatment of the mindbody dualism question. Diseases of the brain are seen as tragedies visited on people.
Damasio presents the somatic marker hypothesis, a proposed mechanism by which emotions guide or bias behavior and decisionmaking, and positing that rationality requires emotional. Descartes error is a straw man, since the idea of a disembodied soul is, to say the least, not taken seriously in modern scientific circles. The ones marked may be different from the article in the profile. A readers journal descartes error emotion, reason, and the.
It reflects a basic ignorance of the relation between brain and mind. Many of its details will survive intact, in my opinion, but it may go off the rails just a bit at one point, in damasios discussion of what he calls the metaself. The distinction between diseases of brain and mind, between neurological problems and psychological or psychiatric ones, is an unfortunate cultural inheritance that permeates society and medicine. Click on a datetime to view the file as it appeared at that time. Damasio antonio r descartes error emotion reason and. Damasio epub version 1894 downloads at 29 mbs in the centuries since descartes famously proclaimed, i think, therefore i am, science has often overlooked emotions as the source of a persons true being. Assembling an explanation d begins by sketching 4 factors in neurobiology of rationality. Emotion, reason, and the human brain paperback september 27, 2005.
288 1189 1609 1568 386 1139 1293 787 1181 1529 1380 506 332 274 1285 2 71 1334 168 1083 959 341 934 1109 217 212 1279 1145 881 132 1223 1011 611 424 1103 570 307 1041